[Tagging] motorcycle:scale

Tom Pfeifer t.pfeifer at computer.org
Mon Feb 4 10:40:52 UTC 2019


On 04.02.2019 08:51, Frederik Ramm wrote:
> * invent keys - ok
> 
> * document widely used/established keys that never went through a
> proposal process - ok
> 
> * invent keys and document them as if they were widely used or
> established - questionable
> 
> * the whole thing done by someone who has in the past unilaterally
> documented their personal preferred tagging on the wiki, then made
> mechanical edits to push it through, and when challenged in changeset
> comments, cited the wiki pages they had edited themselves as an
> authority - ...

It is particularly questionable in this case to mark the documentation as "approved", and include a 
proposal link to a proposal for a different scheme (i.e. mountainbiking). While any other user could 
have convinced me that this was a copy/paste oversight, with the history of a user who had staged a 
fake voting in the past I can only conclude it was intentional.

tom



More information about the Tagging mailing list