[Tagging] Feature Proposal – RFC – natural=peninsula (Was: Feature Proposal – RFC – place=peninsula)
graemefitz1 at gmail.com
Sat Jan 19 01:31:35 UTC 2019
On Sat, 19 Jan 2019 at 10:42, Joseph Eisenberg <joseph.eisenberg at gmail.com>
> “simply map them by what they're called Cape Agulhas is a =cape, Cape York
> Peninsula is a =peninsula.”
> That only works in English (and closely-related languages).
But isn't OSM supposed to work in English (& British English at that)? :-)
> This would also lead to multiple tags like natural=headland, natural=point
> etc for the same feature;
Why would it?
If I've decided to go right round the coast of Australia & map all the
capes, headlands etc & find one that someone has tagged as =point, I'm not
going to also tag it as =headland. If it's existing tagging doesn't really
suit eg the low, sandy Southport Spit is tagged as =headland, I'd probably
change the tag, but I wouldn't put an extra one in.
I agree with Christoph, natural=cape should be tagged on a node to
> represent an extreme point of land, such as a cape, headland, point etc.
> Peninsula should mean an area of land near the coast that is mostly
> surrounded by water, as the etymology shows (“pen-insula” = “almost-island”)
A reasonably sizable area, yes
> Some names capes, like “Cape Cod” in Massachusetts, can be tagged with a
> natural=cape node at the point that extends furthest into the water. This
> is useful for nautical charts and mapping the coastline. But “Cape Cod” is
> also a long, thin peninsula, and this could also be mapped with a node at
> the center of the area of land.
That's right - either as a node or an area
> But the natural=cape of “Land’s End” in Cornwall, England probably is only
> a natural=cape at the extreme point, since the whole Cornwall peninsula is
> not called Land’s End (if I understood English geography correctly)
"Land's End" is the cape which forms the western-most point of the Cornwall
> Some peninsulas will be called something else, like Point Reyes in
& apparently Point Reyes is a cape at the tip of Point Reyes Peninsula
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Tagging