[Tagging] Feature Proposal - RFC - Refugee Site Location

[Warin]

Problem.

The present description does not distinguish this 
'*amenity=refugee_site*' from amenity=social_facility and 
social_facility=shelter.


I would think amenity=refugee_site is an area set aside for the 
non-temporary residential use of refugees. *
*

The meaning of 'temporary' is not stated in the wiki for 
social_facility=shelter so there will be some uncertainty as to where 
teh different lies.

*
*

Possibly the 'area' can be used? A**social_facility=shelter could from 
the wording be considered a single structure? The 'amenity=refugee_site' 
could be stipulated as many structures i.e. mare than 3?



On 14/4/20 5:41 pm, Manon Viou wrote:

> Hello,
> Actually RFC for refugee site location mapping started March 25,
> Since this day, we received and exchanged on the proposal and made 
> changes to the former proposal, that’s what RFC is all about no?  ,
> I do not know if according to this changes, we have to restart the RFC 
> period?
> We will restart RFC period if needed, let me know ! we haven’t 
> received much comments on the latest proposal modifications, please 
> let us know if this works for you or if amendments have to be done ( 
> Proposed features/Refugee Site Location 2 
> <https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Refugee_Site_Location_2>) 
>
> Have a great day,
> Manon
>
>> Le 11 avril 2020 à 00:03, Warin <61sundowner at gmail.com> a écrit :
>>
>> The minimum an RFC is required to be open is 2 weeks.
>>
>> Same with voting.
>>
>>
>> On 11/4/20 1:54 am, Manon Viou wrote:
>>> Hello all,
>>>
>>> We have modified the proposed features/Refugee Site Location 2 
>>> <https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Refugee_Site_Location_2> according 
>>> to discussions regarding how to best tag places sheltering refugee 
>>> and/or internally displace persons. Thank you to the contributors 
>>> who help finding a solution to have a consistent tagging in place 
>>> for refugee location.
>>> We are now suggesting to use the tag *amenity=refugee_site *
>>> The tag can be used alternatively on nodes or on areas:
>>>
>>>   * If the extent of the site is difficult to identify (proximity to
>>>     other villages, suburban area, etc.) it is recommended to use a
>>>     node.
>>>   * If the extent of the site can be clearly identified from the
>>>     imagery or field data collection, it is recommended to use an
>>>     area. Please note this extent does not have to match the
>>>     official boundary of a camp (which doesn’t necessarily coincide
>>>     to its physical limitations), as defined by government and
>>>     specialized agencies, for which a dedicated tag can be used.
>>>
>>> Both approaches can be completed by mapping the landuse=residential 
>>> of the area and if appropriate a tag place (place=neighbourhood, 
>>> place=suburb, place=village) can be added in the area of the refugee 
>>> site.
>>>
>>> Please have a look at this new proposal and share your comments 
>>> quickly if you have any. *We will close RFC period soon*.
>>>
>>> Best regards,
>>>
>>> Manon
>>>
>>> CartONG- Humanitarian mapping and information management 
>>> <http://www.cartong.org>
>>>
>>> Manon Viou
>>>

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/attachments/20200415/28066fb2/attachment.htm>