[Tagging] hiking and foot route relations - is there any consistent difference?

brad bradhaack at fastmail.com
Sat Jan 11 23:54:50 UTC 2020

Great story Kevin.   I hope they learned something from their 
experience.   +1 on the boots,   things change, back in the old days 
when I could still  backpack it was pretty much a given that you should 
have sturdy boots.   Now most of the long distance hikers, like you, 
have gotten wiser and are wearing lighter footwear.

This seems all too typical for OSM.    Redundant tags, and over specify 


On 1/11/20 9:08 AM, Kevin Kenny wrote:
> On Sat, Jan 11, 2020 at 10:03 AM Joseph Eisenberg
> <joseph.eisenberg at gmail.com> wrote:
>> To clarify, I don't see any problem with the existence of multiple
>> tags with similar meanings.
>> But I plan to edit the wiki page to describe how they are actually
>> used, mentioning that there is a wide amoun of overlap in meaning.
> No problem there! In a 'folksonomy', that's going to happen, and as
> someone observed, 'status quo wins.'
> I can recall an encounter that my daughter had on Windham High Peak,
> arguably  the easiest of the Catskill 3500 listed summits (and please
> don't start arguing that Bearpen, Slide, or Hunter is easier, that's
> not the point!) with a father and son who were visiting from a part of
> New Jersey that's both flat and urban.
> Them: "Wow, the guidebook is horrible! It said this is an easy
> three-mile hike from Route 23!"
> Her: "Well, yeah, (looks at phone), GPS says 3.1."
> Them: "That's _easy?_"
> Her: (thinking for a moment): "No scrambling, no broken rock to cross,
> no streams you can't just step over, no dense brush, no deep mud, no
> beaver activitty... what's the problem?"
> Them: (groaning), "I don't want to see a _hard_ trail around here!
> That was straight up hill all the way!"
> Her: "Uhm, well, it _is_ a mountain."
> With subjective assessments that disparate, there are always going to
> be variability and outliers in the tagging.
> The whole discussion of boots is pretty odd. I'm thoroughly a
> Westerner, and I do multi-day backpacking trips in terrain like
> http://image.newyorkupstate.com/home/nyup-media/width2048/img/catskills/photo/2016/05/03/20267771-standard.jpg
> wearing trail-running shoes. The boots come out only when the snow
> does.
> The 'vigour' key is probably a bad one, because it's purely
> subjective. SAC and YDS scale, among others, are also pretty bad
> because almost all 'hiking' routes are at the lowest grade on them,
> and because you really have to be a specialist to grade a route.
> _______________________________________________
> Tagging mailing list
> Tagging at openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

More information about the Tagging mailing list