[Tagging] Denominations vs religions organisations
mwoehlke.floss at gmail.com
Mon Jan 18 13:28:46 UTC 2021
On 16/01/2021 19.35, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:
> The tag "denomination=" is mostly used to tag large categories within a
> particular religion. However, some mappers use this tag to put the specific
> name of a particular church organisation. I believe that is not the best
> idea, and that operator=* should be used for that instead.
> There is a mix of how denomination=* tag is used:
> 1) Most commonly, it is used for the sub-category ('denomination') of a
> religion. The top 20 tags are all like this.
> E.G>. the top religion=christian denominiations are: *catholic*,
> *roman_catholic*, *baptist*, *orthodox*, *lutheran*, *anglican*,
> *protestant*, *methodist*, *russian_orthodox*, *greek_orthodox*,
> *evangelical*, *presbyterian*, *pentecostal*, *jehovahs_witness*, *mormon*,
> *seventh_day_adventist*, *reformed*, etc.
Well... already I can see a number of issues in that list. "Lutheran"
is, at least in the US, insufficiently specific (and *outside* the US,
is often labeled "Evangelical", whereas "Evangelical" *in* the US means
something completely different!), at least "Baptist" and "Orthodox" are
similarly dodgy (the latter doubly so when the more appropriate
Greek/Russian Orthodox are also in the list!), I'm not sure "Catholic"
and "Roman Catholic" are actually different, and many Christians would
argue whether Jehovah's Witnesses should even be labeled "Christian".
(Mormons absolutely are not Christian any more than Muslims are; both
have their own holy books that supersede the Christian Bible.)
This probably needs a page dedicated to spelling out what is an
appropriate level of granularity for each denomination.
> The others are all protestant or marginal categories, not individual
That's not entirely true; at least some of the (US) Lutheran Synods are
definite, actual organizations, although the degree to which individual
congregations actually *follow* the synod can vary.
Also, as Volker noted, I've personally attended churches where the
building is used by multiple organizations. Complicating things, some
churches have schools or day cares that also operate out of the same
More information about the Tagging