[Tagging] Parking lane tagging - city_parking_zone as extra condition value

[Mateusz Konieczny]

I am slowly creating
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/city_parking_zone_as_parking:condition_value
(or now, it is mostly copy-paste of that message and not finished)

Noone commented so far - but if anyone feels that it is unwanted/silly idea
it would be much better to comment now rather then 
during vote after investing several hours of work into it.


Dec 19, 2021, 00:00 by tagging at openstreetmap.org:

> This can work with both just proposed tagging and existing one.
>
> I also thought about municipal_parking_zone as value.
>
> This idea relies on following assumptions
>
> * it is useful to gather/tag info "this is a city parking zone" even if 
> further info is not tagged immediately
> * extra info can be added without on site survey (because it is often 
> the same for entire city or the same in entire districts)
> * tagging full info is often obnoxious and hard to maintain, while 
> gathering it with one value would allow coordinated updates across city
>
> Example from Kraków, Poland.
>
> Area and subareas are well defined, but this rules apply only on public roads. 
> See > https://zdmk.krakow.pl/parkowanie/strefa-platnego-parkowania/mapy/mapa-strefy/
> for an official map.
>
> https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/414860799>  is in A1 subarea but
> city parking rules do not apply there as it is internal road 
> of Jagiellonian University from legal viewpoint.
>
> For > https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/294128564>  this parking rules apply.
>
> This info is not obvious and requires survey/research.
>
> Tagging full rules would require noting that
> - parking is paid
> - parking is free on Sundays and during night (from 20.00 to 10.00)
> - charge strongly reduced for residents with long-term permits
>
> The first two rules are (in case that new tagging would be accepted)
>
> parking:condition:*=ticket
> parking:condition:*:conditional=free @ (Su, Mo-Fr 20:00-10:00)
>
> with the current tagging
> parking:condition:*:ticket:time_interval=Mo-Fr 10:00-20:00
> parking:condition:*:free:time_interval=Mo-Fr 20:00-10:00,Su
>
> tagging this requires checking syntax on wiki (or dedicated editor),
> checking exact parking rules on 
> https://zdmk.krakow.pl/parkowanie/strefa-platnego-parkowania/informacje-ogolne-i-oplaty/>  
> and inputting all of that for every single road segment with parkings.
>
> Even with nice interface (I am working on one exactly right now) collecting
> this info would be really obnoxious.
>
> It seems to me that collecting just 
> parking:condition:*=city_parking_zone during survey and later 
> armchair adding
> parking:condition:*:conditional=ticket; free @ (Su, Mo-Fr 20:00-10:00)
> to all
> parking:condition:*=city_parking_zone
> would be better workflow.
>
> There are also some minor benefits:
> And also makes easier to handle changes in rules (Saturdays used to be also free)
> And allows distinguishing between city-operated parking and privately operated
> (residents may have paid parking only for the first one)
>
> And negatives:
> One more extra rule to suppport and understand.
>

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/attachments/20220113/984b9df1/attachment-0001.htm>