[Tagging] Honesty Boxes / (incl. Schnappsbrunnen in Schwarzwald)? (unstaffed “shops“ selling things based on honour system)

[kaartjesman at mykolab.com]

On zondag 29 mei 2022 16:15:58 CEST Amanda McCann wrote:
> Mostly, the value in a `shop` tag is based on what is sold
> (e.g. `shop=clothes`) rather than the *type* of shop it is.
> Hence `shop=honesty_box` sounds like a shop that sells actual
> boxes. Perhaps `amenity=honesty_box` is best?

The place of commerce you call an "honesty box" feels like it 
just has one small detail that is different in a place. Its not a 
new amenity.
There is simply no human or other means to oversee honesty.

Practically its still a store or vending machine or whatever. I 
don't think it is even relevant to tag there being oversight or 
not to OSM users.
Practically the only users that would use this are the dishonest 
ones, I'm afraid.

Some existing tags that are about the results/effects may be 
enough.
I'm thinking that payment with cash only is relevant (in the 
likely case of there not being a card terminal) and indeed 
"automated=no" may be a nice addition (stolen from node 
9152824604)

Is there any reason not covered by this that a new amenity would 
cover?