[talk-au] Removing tags from way 169174227 "Blue Mountains National Park"

[Ian Sergeant]

Hi,

To me it seems like you've addressed the issues comprehensively.

I see no reason at all to keep the redundant way.  It's just messy.

If people want to see the history, or get a copy of the way, then
that's easy enough to do - even after it's deleted.

Ian.

On 27 January 2016 at 11:16, Warin <61sundowner at gmail.com> wrote:
> Hi,
>
> The way 169174227 is tagged;
>
> name=Blue Mountains National Park
>
> boundary=national_park
>
> This covers a very large area ... that is;
>
> part of the Blue Mountains National Park (not the northern section)
>
> all of;
> Yerrandrie State Conservation Area
>
> Yerrandrie Regional Park
>
> Nattai State Conservation Area
> Nattai National Park
>
> Burragorang State Conservation Area
>
> Kanangra-Boyd National Park
>
> Jenolan Karst Conservation Reserve
>
> As such the tags are deceptive.
>
>
> I have added the following relations from LPI Admin. Boundaries;
>
> Blue Mountain National Park (relation 5909718)
> Yerrandrie State Conservation Area (relation 5910215)
> Yerrandrie Regional Park (relation 5910214)
> Nattai State Conservation Area (relation 5910129)
> Nattai National Park (relation 5910128)
> Burragorang State Conservation Area (relation 5910099)
> Kanangra-Boyd National Park (relation 5909870)
> Jenolan Karst Conservation Reserve (relation 5910091)
>
> I am yet to double check for any other major entities within way 169174227
> ... if I find any I'll add those.
>
> These new additions cover most of the area of way 169174227, making way
> 169174227 redundant?
> However I would like to keep the way in the data base for reference, so
> removing the tags and adding a note with a suitable comment
> would look to be a good way of preserving the history and making it easily
> available if needed.
>
> I'll try leaving comments on change sets involving this way and direct them
> here.
>
> So, your thoughts?
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Talk-au mailing list
> Talk-au at openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
>