[Talk-ca] Formatting of Municipality Names (Jarek Piórkowski)

OSM Volunteer stevea steveaOSM at softworkers.com
Mon Feb 19 23:44:42 UTC 2018


> On 2018-02-19 05:08 PM, Jarek Piórkowski wrote:
>> Have you passed by talk-gb? They have a fair amount of "St" names and
>> some authority as to how to do things in OSM.

I haven't, but I shall.  As I say quite a bit (in our wiki, e.g. California/Railroads), "it's complicated around here."  THEN, there is what we do about that in OSM.  (Our best).

On Feb 19, 2018, at 3:33 PM, Stewart C. Russell <scruss at gmail.com> wrote:
> The UK has Bury St Edmunds, Chapel St Leonards, Lytham St Annes, Ottery
> St Mary, St Andrews, St Anne, St Austell, St Blazey, St Columb Major, St
> Helens, St Ives, St Monans and St Neots all as town names in OSM. The
> only two "Saint .*" towns in the whole British Isles' OSM are Saint
> Helier and Saint Peter Port, both in the Channel Islands. Both have
> French influences. And just to thumb its nose at us, nearby Alderney has
> the town of "St Anne". So I don't think they can be a great example.

I do not mean to appear to be "the pot calling the kettle black" (even as I sheepishly may).  OSM learns by example, by documenting how we should tag (prescriptive) and how we do tag (descriptive), — this isn't always clear or spelled out — by research such as you've done and by good dialog like here.

> Near "St. Louis" (Missouri - abbreviated that way in OSM), OSM has the
> towns of "Saint Clair" and "Saint James". In the same area, there's St.
> Charles, St. Peters and East St. Louis (IL). In the St. Louis metro
> area, there are roughly 4500 ways named "St\. Louis.*" and roughly 3500
> ways named "St Louis.*". There are also roughly 3500 ways named "Saint .*"
> 
> So this is not a standard well kept.

And we make our point:  OSM doesn't always follow its own rules.  Crowdsourcing can be messy, yet we try to improve day by day.  Thanks to all for getting here!

SteveA


More information about the Talk-ca mailing list