[Talk-GB] OSM point of interest counts in each district as a proportion of FHRS

Andrew Hain andrewhainosm at hotmail.co.uk
Sat Dec 31 10:39:36 UTC 2016


As an exercise in measuring OSM’s coverage I have crunched the numbers in GregRS’s CSV output to calculate the number of OSM candidates in each district as a proportion of the number of FHRS entries that the program reports. The figures are a bit arbitrary and values over 100% are not necessarily wrong. The tool doesn’t cover Northern Ireland.

The list is:

1     Tendring     135.07%
2     Gravesham     117.93%
3     Isles of Scilly     117.81%
4     Rushcliffe     117.58%
5     Blackpool     108.66%
6     East Northamptonshire     108.17%
7     Wellingborough     107.94%
8     Guildford     107.82%
9     Erewash     106.40%
10     Broxtowe     106.14%
11     Argyll and Bute     105.49%
12     Islington     104.16%
13     Gedling     98.48%
14     South Cambridgeshire     97.83%
15     Edinburgh     97.60%
16     Nottingham     97.45%
17     Derbyshire Dales     97.07%
18     Cambridge     96.83%
19     Allerdale     94.78%
20     Wychavon     94.78%
21     West Devon     94.47%
22     Bath and North East Somerset     93.83%
23     Oxford     93.09%
24     Aberdeenshire     92.90%
25     Ryedale     90.70%
26     Mid Devon     89.31%
27     Central Bedfordshire     88.97%
28     Westminster     87.99%
29     South Norfolk     87.13%
30     South Lakeland     86.94%
31     Amber Valley     86.34%
32     Birmingham     85.27%
33     Poole     84.66%
34     Melton     83.60%
35     Lancaster     82.43%
36     Southampton     82.31%
37     South Ribble     81.76%
38     Basingstoke and Deane     81.49%
39     Sevenoaks     81.44%
40     Staffordshire Moorlands     81.22%
41     Camden     81.09%
42     South Hams     80.09%
43     Copeland     79.87%
44     Carlisle     79.84%
45     Gateshead     79.72%
46     Hart     79.69%
47     New Forest     79.65%
48     Winchester     79.49%
49     High Peak     79.23%
50     Eden     78.69%
51     South Tyneside     78.59%
52     Rutland     78.34%
53     Perth and Kinross     77.14%
54     Derby     77.05%
55     East Cambridgeshire     76.82%
56     Shetland Islands     76.34%
57     Breckland     76.18%
58     North East Derbyshire     76.15%
59     Bristol     75.91%
60     Huntingdonshire     75.45%
61     Rother     75.34%
62     Sir Ynys Mon - Isle of Anglesey     75.00%
63     Malvern Hills     74.92%
64     Chelmsford     74.79%
65     Hambleton     74.79%
66     St. Albans     74.31%
67     Sutton     73.25% (corrected)
68     Shropshire     72.57%
69     Ashfield     72.34%
70     Richmondshire     71.91%
71     Lambeth     71.70%
72     Sir Ddinbych - Denbighshire     71.52%
73     Tewkesbury     71.37%
74     Runnymede     71.23%
75     Chesterfield     70.80%
76     Stratford-on-Avon     70.73%
77     Fenland     70.50%
78     South Oxfordshire     70.38%
79     Uttlesford     70.05%
80     York     69.92%
81     Exeter     69.82%
82     West Berkshire     69.75%
83     South Gloucestershire     69.64%
84     Cornwall     69.64%
85     Bromsgrove     69.37%
86     Waverley     69.29%
87     Medway     69.28%
88     Wokingham     69.19%
89     North Dorset     68.99%
90     Wyre Forest     68.86%
91     Cherwell     68.73%
92     Highland     68.55%
93     Taunton Deane     68.41%
94     Cotswold     68.40%
95     Mole Valley     68.32%
96     Eastleigh     67.89%
97     Selby     67.86%
98     West Oxfordshire     67.85%
99     St. Edmundsbury     67.69%
100     East Hampshire     67.66%
101     Test Valley     67.52%
102     Chiltern     67.02%
103     Weymouth and Portland     66.84%
104     Wiltshire     66.35%
105     Midlothian     66.10%
106     Rugby     66.00%
107     Maldon     65.99%
108     Na h-Eileanan an Iar     65.84%
109     Bedford     65.69%
110     East Staffordshire     65.37%
111     Leeds     65.30%
112     Waltham Forest     65.24%
113     City of London     65.10%
114     Wakefield     65.03%
115     East Hertfordshire     64.90%
116     Christchurch     64.74%
117     Three Rivers     64.61%
118     Northumberland     64.60%
119     Darlington     64.55%
120     Abertawe - Swansea     64.31%
121     Gwynedd - Gwynedd     64.16%
122     Reading     64.13%
123     Stroud     63.85%
124     Suffolk Coastal     63.84%
125     East Riding of Yorkshire     63.76%
126     North Hertfordshire     63.68%
127     Cheshire East     63.65%
128     Orkney Islands     63.60%
129     Craven     63.60%
130     Mid Suffolk     63.25%
131     Sheffield     63.22%
132     Tamworth     63.13%
133     Norwich     62.95%
134     Solihull     62.82%
135     Warwick     62.75%
136     North West Leicestershire     62.67%
137     West Dorset     62.61%
138     Kensington and Chelsea     62.53%
139     Surrey Heath     62.34%
140     Vale of White Horse     62.33%
141     North Warwickshire     61.97%
142     Hammersmith and Fulham     61.87%
143     Sandwell     61.83%
144     Aylesbury Vale     61.49%
145     Torbay     61.41%
146     Charnwood     61.31%
147     Ipswich     61.26%
148     South Staffordshire     61.21%
149     Ashford     61.00%
150     East Devon     61.00%
151     Hinckley and Bosworth     60.94%
152     Sir y Fflint - Flintshire     60.85%
153     Richmond upon Thames     60.84%
154     South Derbyshire     60.81%
155     North Somerset     60.70%
156     Wandsworth     60.46%
157     Sir Fynwy - Monmouthshire     60.30%
158     Forest Heath     60.27%
159     Great Yarmouth     60.15%
160     Isle of Wight     59.95%
161     Dacorum     59.91%
162     Scarborough     59.80%
163     Forest of Dean     59.54%
164     Teignbridge     59.22%
165     Harborough     58.92%
166     Chichester     58.85%
167     Redditch     58.82%
168     Coventry     58.64%
169     Swindon     58.55%
170     Newcastle upon Tyne     58.48%
171     Worcester     58.28%
172     Cheltenham     57.93%
173     Broadland     57.70%
174     Portsmouth     57.55%
175     Stafford     57.44%
176     Horsham     57.43%
177     West Lothian     57.40%
178     Hackney     57.39%
179     Halton     57.21%
180     Swale     56.91%
181     Bolsover     56.56%
182     Southwark     56.49%
183     North Kesteven     56.06%
184     Tower Hamlets     56.02%
185     Welwyn Hatfield     55.98%
186     Wycombe     55.66%
187     Canterbury     55.32%
188     Spelthorne     54.89%
189     Blaby     54.55%
190     Herefordshire     54.15%
191     Sedgemoor     54.07%
192     Colchester     53.89%
193     Reigate and Banstead     53.47%
194     Newark and Sherwood     53.38%
195     Hertsmere     53.31%
196     Lichfield     53.30%
197     County Durham     53.03%
198     Maidstone     52.81%
199     Aberdeen     52.78%
200     Milton Keynes     52.67%
201     South Northamptonshire     52.40%
202     Cheshire West and Chester     52.10%
203     Tunbridge Wells     52.10%
204     Mendip     52.07%
205     Braintree     51.93%
206     Harrogate     51.62%
207     Bassetlaw     51.60%
208     Glasgow     51.49%
209     Woking     51.29%
210     Babergh     51.14%
211     Walsall     51.13%
212     Bro Morgannwg - the Vale of Glamorgan     51.00%
213     Brent     50.87%
214     East Dorset     50.70%
215     Epsom and Ewell     50.29%
216     Brighton and Hove     49.82%
217     North Norfolk     49.77%
218     Sir Gaerfyrddin - Carmarthenshire     49.75%
219     Stockton-on-Tees     49.68%
220     Bournemouth     49.58%
221     Kettering     49.55%
222     Boston     49.32%
223     Conwy - Conwy     49.15%
224     Wirral     49.01%
225     Haringey     48.84%
226     Tonbridge and Malling     48.72%
227     Telford and Wrekin     48.71%
228     Sefton     48.68%
229     King's Lynn and West Norfolk     48.49%
230     Powys - Powys     48.38%
231     East Lothian     48.31%
232     Ribble Valley     48.06%
233     Daventry     48.05%
234     Newcastle-under-Lyme     47.93%
235     Leicester     47.72%
236     Shepway     47.59%
237     Manchester     47.57%
238     Lewisham     47.47%
239     Tandridge     47.47%
240     Luton     47.42%
241     Kirklees     47.39%
242     Torridge     46.97%
243     Bury     46.75%
244     North Devon     46.75%
245     Harrow     46.67%
246     Rushmoor     46.63%
247     Pen-y-bont ar Ogwr - Bridgend     46.38%
248     Stockport     46.33%
249     Sunderland     46.33%
250     Wealden     46.25%
251     Purbeck     46.24%
252     Stevenage     46.06%
253     Caerdydd - Cardiff     46.02%
254     Sir Ceredigion - Ceredigion     46.02%
255     Barrow-in-Furness     45.89%
256     Fareham     45.86%
257     Windsor and Maidenhead     45.75%
258     Havant     45.44%
259     Bromley     45.40%
260     Elmbridge     45.30%
261     Fylde     45.14%
262     West Lindsey     44.72%
263     Mansfield     44.69%
264     Crawley     44.56%
265     East Lindsey     44.54%
266     Dartford     44.44%
267     Chorley     44.35%
268     Rochford     44.12%
269     East Dunbartonshire     44.11%
270     West Lancashire     43.97%
271     Dudley     43.96%
272     Broxbourne     43.30%
273     South Holland     42.97%
274     Barnsley     42.92%
275     Oadby and Wigston     42.81%
276     Wrecsam - Wrexham     42.59%
277     Kingston upon Hull     42.42%
278     West Somerset     42.40%
279     Bracknell Forest     42.28%
280     East Renfrewshire     42.27%
281     Castell-nedd Port Talbot - Neath Port Talbot     41.35%
282     Wyre     41.27%
283     Fife     41.05%
284     South Bucks     41.03%
285     Casnewydd - Newport     41.00%
286     Barnet     40.68%
287     Trafford     40.54%
288     Lewes     40.52%
289     Brentwood     40.52%
290     Harlow     40.48%
291     Thanet     40.37%
292     Greenwich     40.17%
293     Arun     40.14%
294     Thurrock     40.10%
295     Bradford     39.99%
296     Gloucester     39.97%
297     Angus     39.75%
298     South Ayrshire     39.67%
299     Barking and Dagenham     39.48%
300     Hartlepool     39.46%
301     Scottish Borders     39.35%
302     North Tyneside     39.28%
303     Liverpool     39.23%
304     South Kesteven     39.21%
305     Mid Sussex     39.16%
306     Tameside     38.94%
307     Newham     38.93%
308     Wolverhampton     38.83%
309     Moray     38.45%
310     Plymouth     38.39%
311     South Lanarkshire     38.33%
312     Dover     38.22%
313     Epping Forest     38.08%
314     Middlesbrough     37.72%
315     Lincoln     37.70%
316     Caerffili - Caerphilly     37.57%
317     Merton     37.08%
318     Croydon     37.00%
319     South Somerset     36.84%
320     Enfield     36.54%
321     Ealing     36.48%
322     Stoke-on-Trent     36.44%
323     Hounslow     36.12%
324     North Lanarkshire     35.70%
325     Rhondda Cynon Taf - Rhondda Cynon Taf     35.61%
326     Kingston upon Thames     35.56% (16/12)
327     North Lincolnshire     35.39%
328     Dundee     35.01%
329     Sir Benfro - Pembrokeshire     34.95%
330     Gosport     34.93%
331     Hyndburn     34.88%
332     Hastings     34.63%
333     North East Lincolnshire     34.53%
334     Waveney     34.42%
335     Northampton     34.34%
336     Bexley     34.26%
337     Corby     33.71%
338     Watford     33.59%
339     Preston     33.45%
340     Southend-on-Sea     33.26%
341     Calderdale     32.53%
342     Slough     32.35%
343     North Ayrshire     32.06%
344     Hillingdon     31.54%
345     Nuneaton and Bedworth     31.36%
346     Pendle     31.01%
347     Falkirk     31.01%
348     Redcar and Cleveland     30.91%
349     Adur     30.64%
350     Rotherham     30.46%
351     St. Helens     29.95%
352     Warrington     29.91%
353     Tor-faen - Torfaen     29.53%
354     Blackburn with Darwen     29.37%
355     Peterborough     29.15%
356     Salford     29.13%
357     West Dunbartonshire     29.10%
358     Cannock Chase     28.77%
359     Knowsley     28.60%
360     Redbridge     28.54%
361     Merthyr Tudful - Merthyr Tydfil     27.64%
362     East Ayrshire     27.62%
363     Rochdale     27.18%
364     Rossendale     27.16%
365     Havering     26.80%
366     Worthing     25.83%
367     Oldham     25.74%
368     Renfrewshire     25.52%
369     Bolton     25.21%
370     Wigan     25.07%
371     Basildon     23.95%
372     Clackmannanshire     23.84%
373     Inverclyde     22.45%
374     Doncaster     21.91%
375     Castle Point     19.71%
376     Burnley     17.98%
377     Eastbourne     16.24%

--
Andrew
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/attachments/20161231/ba23e41f/attachment-0001.html>


More information about the Talk-GB mailing list