[talk-pr] Etiquetas ambiguas en las relaciones de ruta

[JOSE L CUEVAS]

Clay,

1. I personally don’t have any issues with the initiative, other than I like primary_urban better. Other than Victor Im not sure you will get much more feedback for consensus on this list.

2. The network tags (shields-puerto-rico branch) will be:

	US:PR:primary (escutcheonShieldBlue)
	US:PR:primary_urban (escutcheonShield)   	(assuming this will be changed from US:PR:urban_primary
 	US:PR:secondary (pentagonShieldBlueYellow)
 	US:PR:tertiary (ovalShield)

3. The minimum tags required for the reference are:

	network = US:PR:primary  (Network tag)
	ref = 1   (Road number shown on shield)
	route = road
	type = route
	direction = west  (As applicable,  north/south/east/west or N/S/E/W )


4. As to the how do we go about adding the references:

4.1. Do you guys have a batch process to create the references, Minh mention that they could use actual road imagery, kind of hinting you guys have something?

4.2. Using the road number can take care of the bulk and later follow up with a more detailed cleanup/fix of edge cases:

	Primary roads are numbered in the 1 to 99 range.
	Secondary roads are numbered in the 100 to 299 range
	Tertiary roads are numbered in the 300 to 9999 range

4.3. When I get back home I can look at what data/sources we can use and start working on adding references.


5. Im going to post a github issue with the errors in Safari.


> On Jul 16, 2022, at 2:23 AM, Clay Smalley <claysmalley at gmail.com> wrote:
> 
> Hi Jose, Victor and others,
> 
> I'm Clay, another maintainer of Americana. I've been doing extensive work on route shields, both locally and internationally.
> 
> I'd like to extend an invitation to everyone here to join the OpenStreetMap-US Slack [1], if you aren't already on it. There's plenty of lively discussion among mappers of the US mainland, but Puerto Rico is mostly missing. We'd love to have a home in the Slack for mappers of Puerto Rico, as well as see more Puerto Rican perspectives in national discussions.
> 
> On Fri, Jul 15, 2022 at 7:33 PM JOSE L CUEVAS via talk-pr <talk-pr at openstreetmap.org> wrote:
> 3. The format for the network tag (1) is (discussion so far):
> 
>         US:PR:<NETWORK_NAME>
> 
> 4. Official road networks in PR (2)(3)(4) are (normalized in uppercase):
> 
>         PRIMARY
>         PRIMARY_URBAN  (URBAN_PRIMARY?)
>         SECONDARY
>         TERTIARY
> 
> All caps is usually used for abbreviations. Most other countries use lowercase to distinguish networks like these.
> 
> I personally like primary_urban better than urban_primary, because sorting alphabetically is coincidentally the same as sorting hierarchically. Not to mention it follows Spanish word order.
>  
> 6. What network name will be used for National Forest Highway (6) ? Looking at shield_def.js don’t see a tag.
> 
> We're still figuring that out [2]. The shield artwork is already in the repository, but the community hasn't determined a consistent tagging scheme for these routes yet. For now, maybe just leave a note on the route relation for Forest Highway 191. Once a consistent tagging scheme is adopted, this relation will be updated shortly thereafter.
> 
> 7.2. Im reading the CONTRIBUTE.md but don’t quite get how the magic of mapping the network tag to a sprite works. 
> 
> I have my definitions in shield_def.js, I get my images included in the sprite.png and json files. Im using your OSM examples in Guyama but still haven’t got the shields to work. I also tried using other images or using one of the built-in drawing shapes like roundedRectShield, etc.
> 
> Any pointers would be appreciated...
> 
> Unfortunately, vector tiles do not update as often as OSM data. In the future, we hope to have a system that pulls OSM data on a regular basis, but for now we have to run updates manually, no more than once a week. The relations in Guayama were modified after the most recent tile update.
> 
> I have a pull request ready for shields of Puerto Rico [3]. We're just waiting for confirmation that there's consensus around this tagging scheme, and for more route relations to be mapped. After that, we can run a tile update, and things should work like you'd expect.
> 
> [1] https://slack.openstreetmap.us/
> [2] https://github.com/ZeLonewolf/openstreetmap-americana/issues/246 
> [3] https://github.com/ZeLonewolf/openstreetmap-americana/pull/497
>  
> _______________________________________________
> talk-pr mailing list
> talk-pr at openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-pr