[Talk-transit] Stop according to new PT scheme not rendered?

[Simon Legner]

Hi!

On 09/12/13 16:33, Jo wrote:
> Could somebody fix the validator in JOSM? A node with highway=bus_stop
> should not cause a warning when assigned a platform role in a route
> relation. I also fail to see why stop and platform roles are needed in
> stop_area relations. It's obvious which is which.

JOSM dev here.

The big problem concerning PT validation (in my opinion) is that it is 
unclear whether to validate according to the old scheme, or to the new 
scheme, or to the old+new scheme (when using stop_positon and bus_stop 
at the same time).
One cannot determine this from the members/roles since that is what you 
want to validate. Having a meta-tag PT:version=<empty>/v1/v2/v1;v2 (v1 
for old, v2 for the new, v1;v2 for old+new) on the route-relation would 
make many things easier.

Cheers,
Simon