[Talk-us] GNIS tag removal proposal
emacsen at gmail.com
Wed Aug 21 17:39:27 UTC 2013
On Wed, Aug 21, 2013 at 1:09 PM, Jason Remillard
<remillard.jason at gmail.com> wrote:
> Hi Serge,
> - If there are two tags for the feature id, we should pick one and
> change the other one.
There aren't two tags for feature_id, there's only feature_id.
This UUID tag appears to be related to the import script itself, and
isn't part of the GNIS dataset.
> - I would be ok with removing all of the gnis:* tags except the
> feature id. There is no reason for us to maintain the other data.
There was another, gnis:fcode, I believe, which people wanted
preserved. My solution to this ambiguity is to explicitly list the
tags to remove, rather than say "All gnis tags except X,Y ,Z"
> - You might want to keep the ele tags.
We don't keep elevation data in OSM- there are other datasets for
that, and they do a far better job.
There were some objections raised about removing elevation for peaks
(and now another POI), but for schools and other places, elevation is
not part of the data.
More information about the Talk-us