[Talk-us] perceptions of OHM and other similar projects

Russ Nelson nelson at crynwr.com
Sat Apr 4 04:08:45 UTC 2015

Richard Welty writes:
 > [OHM is] a real database, using the OSM software stack. it's live, and you
 > can pan around in it and not see much because it's pretty sparse.

The problem, as I see it, is that railroads are a contiguous
whole. Yet some people seem to think that a railroad should be shopped
up along its length, with part of it appearing in OSM (where you can
see it on the ground), and part of it appearing in OHM (where it has
been bulldozed away).

If the two were layers in the same database, or if they have been
tagged using railway=dismantled and railway=abandoned, then it's no
problem to look at them, render them, edit them, analyze them. But
that's not how it works. The databases are completely separate from
each other. An edit in one isn't made in the other.

So let's say that I'm out doing field work with my GPS (Hi,
Frederik!!), and I see that the railroad that I *thought* was distinct
from the highway, actually *is* the highway. Not dismantled, it's now
the road. So I have to go into OHM, delete it from there, go into OSM,
and add the highway to the railroad's relation.



Relations are completely broken. Relations only work within the same
database. It becomes impossible to give a single referent to a
railroad, even if a substantial portion of it is still visible, or
even still has tracks.

Look at the West Side Railroad on the east side of Syracuse. There are
still tracks in Canal Street. Very well, that's in OSM tagged
"disused". Further down Canal Street there are no tracks. So in OHM
tagged "dismantled". East of Canal Street you can see the embankment,
so in OSM tagged "abandoned".

I realize that some people just don't care about railroads. I'm 57, I
know what a "foamer" is, I try not to be one. All I want is to be left
alone with my "model railroad" to share with my fellow foamers. All I
ask is that you not delete abandoned railroads from OSM.

Please, if anybody thinks I'm being ridiculous, going overboard,
suggesting a strawman that nobody actually wants, please say so.

--my blog is at    http://blog.russnelson.com
Crynwr supports open source software
521 Pleasant Valley Rd. | +1 315-600-8815
Potsdam, NY 13676-3213  |     Sheepdog       

More information about the Talk-us mailing list