[Openstreetmap] Sucky sucky OS maps
David Cantrell
david at cantrell.org.uk
Tue Oct 25 12:27:29 BST 2005
One criticism often levelled at efforts like Openstreetmap is that
cartography is as much an art as a science, and that knowing what to
include what to leave out; which features to emphasise and which not to;
which colours to use - to do this well takes a great deal of skill and
experience.
Pity, then, that the dumb bastards responsible for the OS's "Outdoor
Leisure" maps of the Lake District decided to go with bright purple
lines a couple of millimetres thick to denote the boundary of National
Trust-owned land, completely obscuring the roads, footpaths, bridleways
etc along which those boundaries run. It is not easy in some cases
to determine whether a footpath coming towards such a boundary, touching
it, then appearing to leave it was just a bend in the path or a
junction. Likewise with minor roads, whose yellow colouring is
completely washed out by the useless bright purple boundary. This makes
it Quite Hard to plan a route, and if you can't tell people which route
you're following when walking across the fells at this time of year that
is dangerous.
Thankfully, there was a hand-drawn and photocopied map stuck on the
noticeboard of the Youth Hostel we were staying in, which was much more
helpful. So much for professional cartography.
--
David Cantrell
More information about the talk
mailing list