[OSM-talk] open data

[Mike Collinson]

At 11:28 PM 21/09/2006, Etienne wrote:
>I might be wrong, but I think that the main reason originally for 
>using SA was to encourage consumers of the data to contribute their 
>modifications and enhancements back to OSM.  The idea was that this 
>would provide that magical exponential drive for the project.
>
>If we don't get any consumers then there will be no modifications to 
>hand back, so we are cutting off our noses to spite our faces.
>
>Its also very obvious now that contributors and consumers are really 
>two very different types of user.  Most contributors are wizzing 
>around the countryside on bicycles with GPS units and cameras - and 
>they seem to find this a very enjoyable activity in its own 
>right.  most consumers of the data are going to be small companies, 
>associations, groups and individuals who cannot afford commercial 
>map license fees but have no time or interest in making maps 
>(there's a gap between contributor and consumer where some people 
>might be able to make some money).
>
>Since collecting the data and making the base maps is so much fun 
>there is clearly no need to drive OSM by contributions back from 
>consumers.  Its doing very well without them.
>
>There is also evidence that map publishers faced with a choice 
>between using OSM data under the current license and not producing a 
>map at all, will alway choose the latter option.
>
>There does not appear to be a good case for continuing to use the SA license.
>
>Etienne

Well said!

As an individual and OSM member, I really enjoy whizzing about on my 
bike and will continue contributing no matter how this debate turns 
out; I respect the majority.

As the head of a small company, I would be neglecting my duty if I 
recommended using OSM in our commercial products with the current 
license and lack of clear policy.

So I'd go further and restate the first para above: the 
SA  discourages consumers of the data from contributing their 
modifications and enhancements back to OSM.

Mike
Oz