[OSM-talk] Karlsruhe schema with address ranges
Brian Quinion
openstreetmap at brian.quinion.co.uk
Tue Jul 21 15:57:15 BST 2009
>> > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Proposed_features/House_numbers/Karlsruhe_Schema#Sub-proposal:_ranges_of_numbers_for_individual_nodes
> I've done a lot of addr:housenumber=10-23
> Sometimes I've added a node for each entrance.
> I've even done some funky stuff with writing (even)/(odd) in there, but
> that's probably not such a good idea. I was just following the principal of
> recording the information to figure out what works later.
I think that parsing this sort of tag set is very tricky because it
might overlap with other valid tags, for instance some building
addresses are 'The Water Works, 1-4 Testing Avenue' and I'm not sure
that interpolating the building numbers in this case would be correct.
If you use the proposed:
addr:interpolation=odd/even/all
tag suggested in the subproposal it at least gives the parser some
hint that the building number should be handled in this special way.
Personally from the point of view of parsing simplicity I'd prefer two
nodes within the building polygon using the standard Karlsruhe Schema
- parsing it is difficult enough with out adding huge numbers of
exceptions!
--
Brian
More information about the talk
mailing list