[OSM-talk] Proposed Semi Mechanical Edit : "recycling:excrement"

Bryce Nesbitt bryce2 at obviously.com
Fri Apr 17 19:02:23 UTC 2015


On that node I got tripped up because "vending"="excrement_bags" seems to
be used with and without "amenity"="vending_machine"
I followed tagging of nearby nodes in josm, but missed reading the wiki
convention. Sorry.

The overpass query to find other similar tags is:
["vending"="excrement_bags"]["amenity"!~"."] ({{bbox}});

"vending_machine" though still seems a strange tag, as the dog waste
dispensers are very often free, and vending is described as involving money
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Dvending_machine




This is another tag that, in part because there is no guidance from
*osm-carto* rendering, is poorly standardized:

  83  amenity  dog_waste_bin   26  waste_basket  dog_waste   25  amenity
dog_waste_station   23  amenity  dog_waste   11  amenity  dog_waste_basket
11  waste  dog_waste   8  amenity_1  dog_waste_bin   4  name  Dog waste
station   3  type  dog_waste   2  amenity  dog_waste_bag_dispencer   2
description  Dog waste bin   2  name  Dog waste bin   1  ref  Dog Waste Bin
1  amenity  Dog waste bag dispenser   1  amenity  dog waste bin   1
amenity  dog_waste_bags   1  type  dog waste   1  name  Dog Waste Bags
  7 866  vending  excrement_bags   154  waste  dog_excrement   81  waste
excrement   21  type  excrement_bags   6  name  excrement bags   6  name
excrement_bags   6  waste  trash;dog_excrement   2  amenity  dog_excrement
2  type  dog_excrement_bags   2  waste  excrement;grey_water   1  type
dog_excrement   1  description  Dog excrement hot spot   1  note
Integriert: "amenity=waste_basket + waste=dog_excrement"   1  note
Integriert: . basiert auf ungenauer gps-Messung   1  waste_basket
excrement_bags   1  waste  dog_excrement;litter   1  product  excrement_bag
  9  source  captainslash.com/nan-two-go-sliding-in-the-wet-red-shit/   2
type  dog_shit   1  amenity  dog_shit_box
  8 293  waste_basket   1 037  waste_basket:excrement_bags   6
waste_basket:type:nl   1  basket:excrement_bags  9
 dogshit
  note
 dog poop
  55
 recycling:excrement  99
 disused:recycling:excrement
  1 037  waste_basket:excrement_bags   34  excrement_bags   9  bags   1
Bagshaw   1  basket:excrement_bags
Rather than hoping mappers come by to fix them one at a time, this seems
like a good candidate for a mechanical edit.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk/attachments/20150417/416b09fb/attachment.html>


More information about the talk mailing list