[OSM-talk] Villages with no highways

Warin 61sundowner at gmail.com
Sun Apr 8 21:03:40 UTC 2018

In Papua New Guinea there are villages without roads ... people there travel by foot, plane or boat!

The terrain is such that vehicle roads, even for bicycles, is impractical.

I don't have detailed knowledge of Africa to say if these villages could be real or not... but I would hesitate to delete them without that knowledge.
Possibly question the original mapper or a mapper active locally or
failing any of that producing results demote them to locality and await a mapper with on ground experience.

On 09/04/18 06:31, Frederik Ramm wrote:
> Hi,
> On 04/08/2018 10:26 PM, Frederik Ramm wrote:
>> Not only that, someone has already picked them out:
> Looking a bit more at the list, I wonder if we should maybe delete all
> nodes that
> * were imported before 2010 from GNS
> * were never used since
> * have a "fixme=no population estimate available, defaulted to village"
> * and have no mapping in the vicinity
> I have the impression that many of these nodes are stranded in the
> wilderness between several, meanwhile-mapped, populated places, and the
> danger of getting lost while trying to reach one of these places might
> outweigh the advantage of having them.
> Bye
> Frederik

More information about the talk mailing list