[OSM-talk] Attribution guideline status update

Nuno Caldeira nunocapelocaldeira at gmail.com
Mon Sep 9 17:08:46 UTC 2019

Today i was check the maps on their website and noticed they have a 
report button, which i thought would create a note on OSM. Oh i was 
wrong, no note on OSM, wonder where that report will go to. Also quite 
funny that once you submit you get a message "your feedback help us to 
*_make Facebook maps_* better for everyone"....had that ahah moment. 
Example i just done, feel free to try it yourself on the so called 
Facebook Maps https://youtu.be/FF6rOOO51Ig

If anyone can reach them and ask them where that report goes i would 
like to know. I could email them, but they still haven't replied to 
several of my emails.

Another great example of promoting the growth of open data by corporate 
member of OSMF. Great citizens of OSMF.

These loopholes are already being exploited, especially from corporate 
members of OSMF Mapbox (they have several articles, medium tutorials and 
such where's no attribution) and Facebook. Which is a shame, as they are 
well aware of the spirit of OSM.

Oh and by the way, today makes one year i first sent an email to 
Facebook asking to comply. 

Also makes 3 months i have asked the board to terminate Facebook rights 
under ODbL (no decision as fair as i know) 

Meanwhile, Facebook did attribute on some maps, not on all. Evidence 
gathered in July of no attribution, that i just confirmed still not 
fixed. The most hilarious is their app Local, which uses OSM data but 
there's a reasonable calculated logo of HERE on the left corner of the 
map https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1B5AF2i0Go5_jQfuoO26d5mfbi0XE-vg_

Às 15:37 de 09/09/2019, Mateusz Konieczny escreveu:
> Unfortunately proposed version contains
> major loophole that will be deliberately
> exploited by organisation like Facebook
> or Maps.me or Mapbox that describe
> OSM data as their own.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk/attachments/20190909/acb5273f/attachment.html>

More information about the talk mailing list