[OSM-dev] DELETE + body not commonly implemented

bvh bvh-osm at irule.be
Thu May 15 06:23:10 BST 2008

On Wed, May 14, 2008 at 09:20:57PM -0400, Christopher Schmidt wrote:
> One of the bigger changes in the 0.6 API from an implementation
> perspective for clients may well be the use of a content body on DELETE
> requests. kleptog found that to be the most difficult part of
> implementing the changeset/versioning support for JOSM, I think, and I
> think that a number of libraries may make this more difficult than one
> would first assume, since DELETE+body is rather unusual.
> There are two different ways to implement an alternative without
> requiring changes to other code, neither of which would be particularly
> difficult to implement, I don't think: 
>  * Use ?query=string&args=forinfo
>  * Use Version:/Changeset: headers.
* Use DELETE /api/0.6/way/#id/#version

> Either of these will probably work in a wider variety of HTTP clients,
> some of which explicitly don't support including data in a DELETE
> 'natively'.

And if they support it, it is likely a less well tested future with
bigger possibility of bugs.

> What HTTP libraries are people using to talk to OSM? Do they easily
> support DELETE with content body?

Qt support this.

cu bart

More information about the dev mailing list