[HOT] Nepal: Hospital import gone wrong?

Kretzer kretzer at gmx.net
Mon May 4 07:03:01 UTC 2015


Maybe at some point a wrong coordinate system was used for conversion? Like from the .shp to .kll. 
(that's usually the reason why my GIS imports end up in the wrong place ...)

It would be great if these important data could be of use in the end. 


Gesendet mit der GMX iPhone App

Am 04.05.15 um 07:51 schrieb Heather Leson

> Hello, my contacts advised that they are following up.  A quick note that
> 
> this is a WHO dataset, not OCHA. If any files or notes could reflect that
> 
> great.
> 
> 
> 
> If there is any update I will let you know. It might take some time due to
> 
> timezones and approvals by different UN groups.
> 
> 
> 
> Thank you again for your work and advocacy.
> 
> 
> 
> Heather
> 
> On May 4, 2015 8:15 AM, "Heather Leson" <heatherleson at gmail.com> wrote:
> 
> 
> 
> > Thank you.
> 
> >
> 
> > Inquiry sent.
> 
> >
> 
> > Heather
> 
> > On May 4, 2015 8:02 AM, "Prabhas Pokharel" <prabhas.pokharel at gmail.com>
> 
> > wrote:
> 
> >
> 
> >> Heather,
> 
> >> 2. The dataset was the following
> 
> >> https://data.hdx.rwlabs.org/dataset/nepal-health-facilities-cod
> 
> >> 1. Megha went through and manually matched up health facilities in the
> 
> >> Kathmandu Valley, because KLL has formerly surveyed and created a rigorous
> 
> >> dataset in the valley. A majority of the conflicts in the valley were
> 
> >> deleted. Since the second dataset doesn't have names, match up was done by
> 
> >> location. Please follow up with Megha on the rest.
> 
> >>
> 
> >> If we get a compatible license, the other route we could go through
> 
> >> (instead of re-instanting the changeset) is to do a more rigorous import,
> 
> >> after checking that the health facility locations seem legitimate (not in
> 
> >> forests, near residences, etc.) and not in conflict with existing
> 
> >> facilities with HOT's help.
> 
> >>
> 
> >> cheers,
> 
> >> Prabhas
> 
> >>
> 
> >> On Mon, May 4, 2015 at 10:41 AM, Heather Leson <heatherleson at gmail.com>
> 
> >> wrote:
> 
> >>
> 
> >>> Hi Pierre is sleeping. I would normally ask him and activation. I will
> 
> >>> ask a contact via UN OCHA (offlist) and report back to activation
> 
> >>>
> 
> >>> What I need is:
> 
> >>> 1. Confirmation that the changeset link includes the full dataset (the
> 
> >>> link below )
> 
> >>> 2. Exact source link for the dataset.
> 
> >>>
> 
> >>> I will ask for a license update.
> 
> >>>
> 
> >>> Does this sound ok?
> 
> >>>
> 
> >>> Heather
> 
> >>>
> 
> >>> The file is
> 
> >>> On May 4, 2015 7:48 AM, "Prabhas Pokharel" <prabhas.pokharel at gmail.com>
> 
> >>> wrote:
> 
> >>>
> 
> >>>> > A very sad one, but nothing to do
> 
> >>>> > about it, unless the copyright holders let us upload the data to OSM
> 
> >>>> > without that non-commercial restriction.
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>>> HOT, we must have contacts at UN OCHA, can we start a conversation to
> 
> >>>> ask if they are willing to do it? At the moment, we don't have the
> 
> >>>> bandwidth here at KLL these days to have this conversation. But as I see
> 
> >>>> it, adding POIs and named places onto the map is pretty important to focus
> 
> >>>> on, in parallel with all of the imagery-based work that we are doing.
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>>> cheers,
> 
> >>>> Prabhas
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>>> On Mon, May 4, 2015 at 10:26 AM, Rafael Avila Coya <
> 
> >>>> ravilacoya at gmail.com> wrote:
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>>>> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
> 
> >>>>> Hash: SHA1
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> Hi, Prabhas:
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> I wonder if this data can be incorporated to a local or alternative
> 
> >>>>> database that can be of use in this situation.
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> About the field papers, I don't see any problem to use this data as a
> 
> >>>>> guide of finding those health facilities and correctly geolocate them
> 
> >>>>> while surveying on the ground.
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> Using the GNS and other place nodes already in the database, it might
> 
> >>>>> be possible to add some of this nodes to OSM. It might. But in any
> 
> >>>>> case, the license is a restriction. A very sad one, but nothing to do
> 
> >>>>> about it, unless the copyright holders let us upload the data to OSM
> 
> >>>>> without that non-commercial restriction.
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> Cheers,
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> Rafael.
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> On 04/05/15 00:26, Prabhas Pokharel wrote:
> 
> >>>>> > Thank you all; two main issues here: one that the dataset
> 
> >>>>> > geolocations are problematic, and two that the license was
> 
> >>>>> > incompatible. Apologies for incorrectly interpreting the license
> 
> >>>>> > here in Nepal.
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > As megha said, the reason we attempted this was because the maps
> 
> >>>>> > that HOTOSM volunteers have helped create via tracing for us is
> 
> >>>>> > amazingly detailed (in terms of residential areas, roads, pre-quake
> 
> >>>>> > buildings), but hard to use because of the lack of POIs on the
> 
> >>>>> > ground. This was an attempt to alleviate the problem, but sounds
> 
> >>>>> > like we did misinterpret the license issue, and apologies for
> 
> >>>>> > that.
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > We simply did not know about the problematic geolocations. However,
> 
> >>>>> > it is worth noting that this dataset is what a lot of organizations
> 
> >>>>> > have been using locally, given that it is the best available
> 
> >>>>> > dataset of health facility locations.
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > Maybe the discussion we need to have soon is how we can improve
> 
> >>>>> > OSM-based tools (MapOSMatic, Fieldpapers, etc) to incorporate
> 
> >>>>> > datasets like this that are very useful in scenarios like what we
> 
> >>>>> > are going through, but are incompatible to put into OSM because of
> 
> >>>>> > the license.
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > cheers, Prabhas
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > On Mon, May 4, 2015 at 9:09 AM, Rafael Avila Coya
> 
> >>>>> > <ravilacoya at gmail.com <mailto:ravilacoya at gmail.com>> wrote:
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > Hi all:
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > Megha (MeghaShrestha), the user that imported these data, has
> 
> >>>>> > answered me through the OSM messaging. She works with the KLL and
> 
> >>>>> > she tells me: "we are trying to create papers for the relief
> 
> >>>>> > workers. The problem being there are enough details like roads,
> 
> >>>>> > buildings, rivers but no POIs in many areas. It is difficult for
> 
> >>>>> > the relief workers to locate themselves on the map. Importing the
> 
> >>>>> > health facilities data was an attempt so that they can at least
> 
> >>>>> > find some POIs they can look for while locating themselves on the
> 
> >>>>> > map. The data I imported was from
> 
> >>>>> > https://data.hdx.rwlabs.org/dataset/nepal-health-facilities-cod.
> 
> >>>>> > The licence says we can use the data for non commercial purpose and
> 
> >>>>> > we need to credit the source. I hope these information are helpful
> 
> >>>>> > and you can help us out."
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > With this info, I can see that the data is the one we were
> 
> >>>>> > discussing a few days ago, although that data set contained almost
> 
> >>>>> > 9,000 nodes, whereas the one of Megha had around 4,660.
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > I recall the main problem: geolocation was very poor (most of nodes
> 
> >>>>> > in well out of any settlements). The other problem I see is the
> 
> >>>>> > license: it's for non-commercial use, and that makes it
> 
> >>>>> > incompatible with the OSM license.
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > I really feel to give a no in such circumstances as these, and
> 
> >>>>> > that's why I ask for more input from other people with experience
> 
> >>>>> > on this, just in case there is any possibility of including the
> 
> >>>>> > data into OSM, and if not what other options we would have to make
> 
> >>>>> > good use of these data set, if any.
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > Cheers,
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > Rafael.
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > On 03/05/15 18:14, Kretzer wrote:
> 
> >>>>> >> When looking at the Gorkha area in #1024 I noticed several nodes
> 
> >>>>> >> tagged as "Hospital" with a lot of information, quoting UNOCHA
> 
> >>>>> >> as source, but obviously in the wrong place, because there is
> 
> >>>>> >> nothing nearby. Like here:
> 
> >>>>> >> http://www.openstreetmap.org/edit#map=19/28.00839/84.62397 Looks
> 
> >>>>> >> like a mass import that somehow went wrong ... shame, because
> 
> >>>>> >> hospitals are important!
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> >> By the way, I am somewhat confused as to what is that called a
> 
> >>>>> >> "task" now? Is it a single tile (with a #) or is it the whole
> 
> >>>>> >> project?
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> >> _______________________________________________ HOT mailing list
> 
> >>>>> >> HOT at openstreetmap.org <mailto:HOT at openstreetmap.org>
> 
> >>>>> > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > _______________________________________________ HOT mailing list
> 
> >>>>> > HOT at openstreetmap.org <mailto:HOT at openstreetmap.org>
> 
> >>>>> > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> >
> 
> >>>>> > -- Prabhas Pokharel http://prabhasp.com
> 
> >>>>> > twitter/skype/facebook/whatever: prabhasp
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> - --
> 
> >>>>> Twitter: http://twitter.com/ravilacoya
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> - --------------------------------
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> Por favor, non me envíe documentos con extensións .doc, .docx, .xls,
> 
> >>>>> .xlsx, .ppt, .pptx, aínda podendoo facer,  non os abro.
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> Atendendo á lexislación vixente, empregue formatos estándares e
> 
> >>>>> abertos.
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> http://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenDocument#Tipos_de_ficheros
> 
> >>>>> -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
> 
> >>>>> Version: GnuPG v1.4.10 (GNU/Linux)
> 
> >>>>> Comment: Using GnuPG with undefined - http://www.enigmail.net/
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>> iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJVRvhtAAoJEB3niTly2pPQ6rYQAIACG4KEtph2xtxQvywpuEsJ
> 
> >>>>> dJujmsakn1Z2R3Cx6RhbB1cpTtwRB5R08WDeDx6veKh2NjyyoYmBk1gpxam0M8m+
> 
> >>>>> nZcyixJxn59vMkVHCLh0kKyBBGNnDAPyQC+GBZtPsW04Vd7Zi8qc3rs98CnE3QHP
> 
> >>>>> gHpXfD/xtiMSi/g/Q6MhQ/DNYOQLLyZn9O2F3zg8UWHFTBFcUE544wnOkKmzmoKF
> 
> >>>>> ORyfN5Z3/d8E6GewV48otvl96S1xVikmLqu3AEDDGugU1llBOIpjG1gpF+yIEDtD
> 
> >>>>> Qq5+2iYGqTWoq/k/fVpuORvWaETHYtORzcTjGbul757gwLZYFwJtrgMsnkjf0KiO
> 
> >>>>> flnL3w6Vh5Ysc/imP5P6p76yg5rxRPhuoSdc0H5OJTExH09sZAwrvqOmjULeYTaX
> 
> >>>>> wfltzd8QJmD7WWLSsVnRVNoNXyPkA6EFB0x5zJklAJdELslAZIrV2X0YPB/bbqDT
> 
> >>>>> TJPob34LoicYoXZ0JPt5VbHPYUTZvHq7HJ8bZzaXOrWblPctb4fz7abUHUMEzl/5
> 
> >>>>> W9KoNx0wJAU1ChJkERV8IxuMwnffwELnw/CUN5p57XJ6PY5vCnuTOPYoScrTwFN4
> 
> >>>>> lfvwRSoMkDsbcmCPotaXJ+lt2egKAZoqWc9T78qEsOUsf9gB1pF2zfvHmTKBQ500
> 
> >>>>> 69oFJ/ArvtOAV2hLDBCx
> 
> >>>>> =b93r
> 
> >>>>> -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
> 
> >>>>>
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>>> --
> 
> >>>> Prabhas Pokharel
> 
> >>>> http://prabhasp.com
> 
> >>>> twitter/skype/facebook/whatever: prabhasp
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>>> _______________________________________________
> 
> >>>> HOT mailing list
> 
> >>>> HOT at openstreetmap.org
> 
> >>>> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>>>
> 
> >>
> 
> >>
> 
> >> --
> 
> >> Prabhas Pokharel
> 
> >> http://prabhasp.com
> 
> >> twitter/skype/facebook/whatever: prabhasp
> 
> >>
> 
> >
> 
> _______________________________________________
> HOT mailing list
> HOT at openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot



More information about the HOT mailing list