[Tagging] Requirements for proposals and voting to be valid
lists at mail.atownsend.org.uk
Wed May 11 12:38:10 BST 2011
On 11/05/2011 12:19, Ilya Zverev wrote:
> I've reverted his edits of the proposal page, but is he right? Is any
> proposal with incorrect subject line in tagging@ post (let along those
> which weren't mentioned here) automatically invalid?
If so most of map features would be "invalid" because many features
there predate the tagging@ list.
The problem is that there are many different versions of "valid" in the
"valid" in the wiki just means that people who read the wiki and can be
bothered to vote thought that it was a good idea.
"valid" on the map means actually used lots of times
"valid" in the editors means that the editor authors thought that a
particular combination was relevant to that editor's target mark
"valid" in the renderers means something different again, etc.
So it seems to me like a valid wiki vote. As to what relevance it has
elsewhere? Not so sure.
More information about the Tagging