[Tagging] sport without pitch but club : ok or tagging mistake ?

[bkil]

I'm not mixing things up, I've raised valid concerns about data
consistency and downstream usability of usage if you mix up the
meaning of tags.

Let me ask a question about your proposal: what if the building was a
multi-story, multi use building, and the sports club operated only in
the north wing on the ground floor? Clearly marking sport=darts for
the whole building complex would be both illogical and misleading,
because you can only play darts on one part and one floor of the
building, hence why it would be a good idea to move this information
to the clubhouse

What if I am a soccer fan but I don't like table soccer, darts or
other indoor sports that much, but I want to watch the match with
friends in a new neighborhood and we would also like to play pool
while at it, hence I would want to query something to the effect of
club=sport + club:sport=*soccer* + sport=*billiards* (whatever keys
you come up for marking this up)? If you split this information to a
separate entity (either to its own sports node or to a building way),
you will lose the ability to realistically search for this.

On Mon, Jun 28, 2021 at 9:52 PM Robin Burek <robin.burek at gmx.de> wrote:
> -> building as clubhouse -> operated by the club (here you can add e.g.
> sport=table_soccer, darts,.... or map them seperate)
> -> node with club=sport, sport=soccer for the club itself.