[Talk-GB] Quarterly project - Feedback to Food Standards Agency?

Gregrs gregrs at fastmail.co.uk
Fri Apr 21 07:21:09 UTC 2017


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

>> A while someone said the Food Standards Agency were aware of the
>> FHRS quarterly project & would welcome feedback or any errors. Did
>> anything get formalised? I've a file of data for my area to pass on,
>> but obtaining a contact within my Local Authority is proving rather
>> difficult.

I haven't formalised anything either, but I would be happy to provide
CSV files from database queries if that would help e.g. a list of FHRS
establishments marked on the comparison tool as having a postcode error.

One other problem with FHRS data that doesn't show up on the comparison
tool is a duplicate FHRS ID (because these fail the primary key
constraint on import and are therefore dropped). I can get a list of
these from running the server scripts manually if that would help.

>I haven't done anything with the data, but I've generally made a point
>of adding not:addr:postcode=* when I came across an incorrect postcode
>in the FHRS data. If others did the same, the comparison tool at
>http://gregrs.dev.openstreetmap.org/fhrs/ could presumably make use of
>such tags and provide a list of postcode errors for each district. (It
>could also use the presence of such a tag to suppress/de-emphasize the
>postcode mismatch errors it reports.

Thanks for that idea, Robert. I have added an issue on GitHub
<https://github.com/gregrs-uk/python-fhrs-osm/issues/44>. I won't have
time to add this feature in the near future but may be able to have a
look over the summer. Contributions from others are always welcome, of
course.

In the meantime, I guess we could create an Overpass Turbo query for
entities with both an fhrs:id and not:addr:postcode tag to generate a
list.

Thanks,
Greg

- -- 
Twitter: @gregrs_uk
http://gregrs.dev.openstreetmap.org
PGP key ID: 64907C8A 
Fingerprint: EBD1 077F CCDD 841E A505 3FAA D2E8 592E 6490 7C8A

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQEcBAEBCAAGBQJY+bLlAAoJEB7WhxSLszZllGAH+wV1wDDJ2JUKkHY2KHQPWVSo
VLZfgv8Ucu4zvixKACgR3Ig/GDA132iolfRj7+cITV0h1tZndrSAcLu5GyemBKB+
TZGag68z8mNgam63wHDS1ft0Bst/CW+FMjxFOsvW6rFlCs0ewlZmizOhw5haD3h4
hCZwWozG89hXq3iCbyIkCrJjEYgc26Eka/Ck0VM4iHwcyrcEz8J1MW9GoctKWGN6
K+x7E9Htqj8163oWm9RT4Tt8n7EgzfzjIOueCE91lDTmbx7S/SQxq/L52tKVowUr
iIV/ZPF1TgHTAbV/dWQwHmdCe6O7ZPNFT59r6ChrzNPdn8YNC2ud6Ru3pP6svBk=
=Uhid
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----



More information about the Talk-GB mailing list