[OSM-talk] Règles d'éditions organisées / Directed editing guidelines
Christoph Hormann
osm at imagico.de
Tue Jun 25 10:27:35 UTC 2019
On Saturday 22 June 2019, severin.menard via talk wrote:
>
> At present, this policy concerning directed editions is therefore,
> paradoxically, not respected or even totally neglected by the main
> organizations it targeted.
This is something by the way i predicted to be the likely outcome of
introducing a vague policy very early in the process leading to these
guidelines. Responsible mappers would invest a lot of work into
following the policy - mostly unnecessarily because since they are
responsible they would do the necessary things even without there being
a policy. Irresponible people however only do the absolute minimum of
the most lenient interpretation of the rules - often garnished with the
usual corporate communication redirection and avoidance strategies.
I also predicted in
https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/Stereo/diary/45132#comment42989
what we now see with the various pro forma attempts at following the
guidelines that many of them respond "in kind" with the with the same
non-commital vagueness as the policy.
Regarding evaluation of the guidelines - although it would certainly be
good if there was a critical evaluation i have very little hope that
there will be such in the near future. It is not that during the past
half year there have been significant developments as a result of the
policy that were not predictable and argued to be the likely outcome
with clear reasoning in advance.
My own conclusion meanwhile is that if there is to be any meaningful
regulation of organized mapping activities it has to come from the
local communities. This is particularly important for still small
communities just starting off to happen before well organized corporate
interests start their coordinated invasion leaving nothing but a data
wasteland for locals to deal with after the invadors have left.
--
Christoph Hormann
http://www.imagico.de/
More information about the talk
mailing list