[OSM-talk] Implement tutorship for newbies

[Marc_marc]

Le 13.02.21 à 18:41, mail at marcos-martinez.net a écrit :
> haven't played around with the neis-one too much but it seems like it is
> focused on detecting edits that are considered problematic

no. for exexmple review_request in France from mapper with <10 days
of mapping without any reply yet.

> https://resultmaps.neis-one.org/osm-suspicious?country=140&hours=96&mappingdays=10&groupby=c&tsearch=review_requested%3Dyes&anyobj=t&comp=%3E&value=10&action=d&obj=n&woc=t

exept the title, nothing suspicious :)

as you can see, review_request for France is already enough to have a
higher demand than what the community provides. as long as the community
is not able to help new contributors who want a review, I am afraid that
offering them something that the community is not able to provide is
even more likely.
when answering old changeset, detected because of a validation problem,
I already have 2x an answer asking why the review_request was proposed
if nobody answers? that's why I'm dubious about proposing an tutorship,
unless there is first a team available and a way to stop the proposal
as soon as the available time is likely to be exhausted

Of course I would like to be wrong and it is of course variable
according to the communities.

Regards,
Marc