[OSM-talk] EG/Doxxing | Re: New moderation team & etiquette guidelines for talk@ & osmf-talk@ list

[Mateusz Konieczny]

I send it also to talk-owner at openstreetmap.org
in attempt to reach moderators

9 cze 2022, 19:51 od ajt1047 at gmail.com:

> On 09/06/2022 18:30, Joseph Eisenberg      wrote:
>
>> I think “edit shaming” is supposed to mean          “insulting or embarrassing someone for spelling, grammar or          typographical mistakes” but it is not at all clear what the          phrase means. 
>>
>>
>
> Some extra definition would certainly help here (including      perhaps some examples) as otherwise translators into other      languages are going to struggle to understand what was meant.
>
>

Clarification would be helpful as I was sure that it is about complaining about
bad edits. And unsure what actually is forbidden - for example is

"HOT organised editing is a problem because quality of edits is very often bad
and HOT fails to either actually help newbie mappers, or verify their edits.
And HOT primarily tries to bring more newbie mappers and reach larger edit
volume, instead of trying to improve quality and at least review all edits
made as part of HOT organised mapping or focus on recruiting repeat mappers
who would map more than once."

qualifying as banned edit shaming?
(for reference: I consider above as a real issue and not an edit shaming
Hmmm, maybe it would be useful to write to HOT - maybe I am wrong
and just encountered the worst kind of HOT activity? Anyone knows
what would be a good contact point? )

Is "hahaha https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/122063728 is useless
pointless armchair mapping and wrong, this line is not existing anymore,
you should stop mapping" qualifying as banned edit shaming?

(for reference: I linked my own edit and as far as I know this railway
line exists, though I was never there. And I consider landuse=railway
mapping as useful
But if it would not be a deliberate example with myself as target then
I would expect it to be an edit shaming - but it seems so rare
and covered by other rules that I am unsure why it got a separate rule)

Or is "hahaha, you missed 'an' article, stop posting" intended to be banned
by edit shaming? Also, why it got a separate rule?

BTW, https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Etiquette/Etiquette_Guidelines#Edit_shaming
never got any resposne.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk/attachments/20220609/51d21665/attachment.htm>